Do you miss a subject, a perspective or would you like to write an article for this site? Contact us!
- ‘Time is over when mankind created wealth by subjecting nature to it’
Latest
If you have any innovation and solution on how we can reduce the impact of plastic waste, EPPIC is the right opportunity for you to pour the ideas and make it come true! With EPPIC, you can help us create a better environment for all!🐟🐋🐠 #aisforum2021 #sustainable #EPPIC pic.twitter.com/eaEBEXn0Hx
Meeting the changing consumer expectations through sustainable supply chains Read our latest report in partnership with @Which50 sap.to/6015HYlvD @SCMatSAP #Sustainability pic.twitter.com/BSbmzAh5fb
About a minute ago from SAP Australia and NZ's Twitter via Sprinklr
CEO's Remove Your #Environmental Social & #Governance ESG pains within 18 Months' #Sustainability #Strategy. CEO Online Boardroom Education buff.ly/3ko0q1U Course #challenges #ClimateActionLive pic.twitter.com/CyQwoAxmuu
About 2 minutes ago from Yusuf Azizullah's Twitter via Twitter Web App
It’s that time of the year. Using nature to provide for yourself is rewarding and fun. Here’s a quick guide for anyone interested in giving it a try #sustainability #outdoors #nature #Canada pic.twitter.com/Jj1cJUqShG
About 3 minutes ago from Meaganelaine's Twitter via Twitter for iPhone
Together with our Automotive customers & partners, @Microsoft is committed to making mobility and transportation safer, productive, more connected, and #sustainable. See how we are partnering with the industry to drive the future of mobility forward. cloudblogs.microsoft.com/indu…
About 3 minutes ago from Sanjay Ravi's Twitter via Twitter for iPhone
#Sustainability is the future, and with our ARL PERFORM'X EDXRF Spectrometer, #nuclear engineers can reduce the time required to identify corrosive elements in water cooling systems from a half-day to minutes per filter. ter.li/ahrxa4
About 3 minutes ago from Microscopy & Spectroscopy's Twitter via CoSchedule
@ChrisCalviFree @GeorgeKCampbell Not by the time they export the Kiwi oats to Europe and then import the ‘milk’ back to NZ #carbonneutral #sustainability
About 4 minutes ago from 03 Mafia's Twitter via Twitter for iPhone
With so much going on in the world, we forget about the world itself. We’re here to help with that 🌎 #share #earth #world #Sustainability #smallworld #SmallBusiness #animals #progress #LetsPlantTrees #eco #GreenEarth #makeadifference
About 6 minutes ago from ORMA's Twitter via Twitter for iPhone
Learn about Interflon USA's 2MP Lubrication System, the next step in your quest for efficiency! interflon.com/us/news/bring-… #lubrication #efficiency #facman #sustainability #innovation
About 7 minutes ago from InterflonUSA (877) FIN-LUBE's Twitter via TweetDeck
Our area is almost set up for the @BrisHomeShow Come have a chat in the #sustainability square #solarinstallers #brisbanehomeshow #MeetTheTeam pic.twitter.com/M2iNQVpNTX
About 9 minutes ago from Expert Electrical AUS's Twitter via Twitter for iPhone
Human error, a category that raises more questions than it answers
Human error is the label stuck on accidents that cannot be directly explained by the failure of a device, be it mechanical, electric or electronic. But the other side of such errors might well be the variation in the way human beings perform tasks and attain goals, a variation essential to the development of society.
Spanish rail accident
One of my favourite blogs on internet is Evolving Excellence, devoted to spread the idea of lean production. A recent blog by Kevin Meyer struck me as particularly to the point. It is about human error in industrial (or indeed any other) operations, based on an article by Steven Shorrock, ‘one of the most insightful articles I’ve read in a long time’, says Meyer. We will closely follow both Meyer’s blog, and Shorrock’s article.
The idea that heads should roll
Shorrock starts out from the following observation. ‘In the aftermath of the [Spain rail] accident, initial investigations ruled out mechanical or technical failure, sabotage and terrorism. That appeared to leave only two possible explanations – ‘human error’ or ‘recklessness’, or both….’ When something bad happens, says Meyer – an accident like this, an inappropriate comment, a disastrous rollout of a website – we seek action, fast. We want accountability, and usually by that we mean rolling heads. Rarely do we probe further into the context of the event, and especially into the system.’
A term devoid of explanatory power
Shorrock then raises the question, if we should unequivocally want to attribute ‘blame’ to someone, whether the driver should be on the receiving side. Maybe the system was ill-devised as well? The train driver would have had to reverse to manual. ‘The ‘reversion to manual’ problem has been studied extensively in the context of automation and manual operation. The distracting effects of phone calls – hands free or not – are well-documented. ‘Multitasking’ is known to have devastating effects on performance, yet conflicts between safety and efficiency goals often demand that we switch from one task to another in a given timeframe.’ The term ‘human error’ in this context would then come close to be an umbrella for a great multitude of actions, unrelated among themselves, and therefore devoid of explanatory power. ‘When something goes wrong, complexity is reduced to this simple, pernicious, term. ‘Human error’ has become a shapeshifting persona that can morph into an explanation of almost any unwanted event. It is now almost guaranteed to be found in news stories pertaining to major accidents.’
The term should be abandoned
And then eventually, Shorrock comes up with the reasons why he is abandoning the term:
• ‘Human error’ is often a post hoc social judgement. ‘Human error’ is one of few things that often cannot be defined unambiguously in advance of it happening.
• ‘Human error’ requires a standard. To know that something is an error, it must be possible to describe a non-error. This can be surprisingly difficult, partly because there are so many “it depends”. In the context of complex interacting systems such as ATC, there are many ways to get an acceptable result.
• ‘Human error’ points to individuals in a complex system. In complex systems, system behaviour is driven fundamentally by the goals of the system and the system structure. People provide the flexibility to make it work.
• ‘Human error’ stigmatises actions that could have been heroic in slightly different circumstances. What are described as heroic actions could often have been described as tragic errors if the circumstances were only slightly different. The consequences of heroic actions are not known in advance.
• Underlying processes of ‘human error’ are often vital for task performance. In the context of error, we often refer to psychological activity involved in perception, memory, decision making or action. Taking one example, without expectation, radio-telephony would be very inefficient. Occasionally, one may hear what one expects instead of what is said, but this must be set against improved efficiency during thousands of other occasions.
• ‘Human error’ is an inevitable by-product of the pursuit of successful performance in a variable world. The context and conditions of performance are often vague, shifting and suboptimal. The ability to adapt and compensate comes at a cost.
Meyer sums up: ‘The need for standards, the importance of context, the fine line between error and heroism, and perhaps even the positive aspects of error when pushing boundaries.’ Shorrock would prefer to use the concept of ‘performance variability’. ‘This is not simply a replacement term or a euphemism, but a new way of thinking that acknowledges how systems really work. Performance variability, both at an individual level and at a system or organisational level, is both normal and necessary, and it is mostly deliberate.’
And Meyer concludes: Something to think about next time an incident happens and you feel that instinctual urge to blame, instead of understand.
http://www.safetydifferently.com/the-use-and-abuse-of-human-error/
http://www.evolvingexcellence.com/blog/
on: 14 December 2013